By Dr. Seleem R. Choudhury
Originally featured in Diversity and Equality in Health and Care, Aug. 28, 2020
Abstract
Population Health invokes an image of helping to improve the health of all within the community however even in recent years a large portion of the community are being further marginalized and failed on a daily basis and this systematic failure is leading to premature deaths and poor health outcomes. Black Lives Matter protests have emphasized the racial disparity evident within the United States and the western world. It’s an opportunity to look beyond the issues of law enforcement and examine one aspect of inequality and examine how Black, Indigenous and People of Colour are impacted by being treated differently within healthcare. Minorities have significantly worse health outcomes than white patients and an understanding needs to occur first and then an evidenced based strategic focus of steps that need to be taken on workplace diversity which can help reduce health disparity within the community and presents value, socially and economically to the healthcare facilities and its surrounding community.
Keywords: health disparities, inequality, Leadership, Workplace Diversity, Premature Deaths, Chronic diseases and Health Outcomes.
Inequality in healthcare
In recent weeks we have seen public protests regarding how African Americans and people of colour are treated by law enforcement. This attention has highlighted the layers of prejudices within the police force and the wider spectrum of our society today. This article highlights that healthcare is not exempt from the delivery of this prejudice.
Health disparities are complex and take on many different forms for racial and ethnic minorities in the United States (National Academies of Sciences & Medicine, 2017) specifically rates of premature deaths and chronic diseases in both urban and rural areas(Henning-Smith, Hernandez, Ramirez, Hardeman, & Kozhimannil, 2019) and this health vulnerability is highlighted in the infection rates and deaths following the emergence of COVID 19 (Laurencin & McClinton, 2020). Just like with any issues, you must first admit you have a problem. Health advocates and most recently, the commonwealth fund says that healthcare organizations, leaders, and professionals must explicitly acknowledge that race and racism factor into health care(Hostetter & Klein, 2018).
The importance of reducing health disparities presents value, both socially and economically. Authors LaVeist, Gaskin, and Richard (2011) stated that eliminating racial health disparities would reduce direct medical care expenditures by about $230 billion and indirect costs associated with illness and premature death by more than $1 trillion the years 2003-2006 (in 2008 inflation-adjusted dollars).
Health outcomes
Minorities still have significantly worse health outcomes than white patients(Allen, Call, Beebe, McAlpine, & Johnson, 2017; Ibarra, Montoya, Romero, & Gonzalez, 2018; Tempe & Dhir, 2019; Yearby, 2018) and the data shows is worse for black Americans (Ferdinand et al., 2017; Howard, 2020). There is compelling evidence that a diverse healthcare workforce positively impacts health outcomes. A study showed that black men who are treated by black doctors were substantially more likely to opt for every test than those with a non-black doctor (Khullar, 2018). An example, patients with black doctors were 47 percent more likely to get diabetes screening and 72 percent more likely to get cholesterol tests.(Alsan, Garrick, & Graziani, 2019).
Cortisol effect
It is well documented that a relationship exists between stress and physiology. There is growing evidence that Black, Indigenous and People of Colour experience higher levels of cortisol, than their non-black counterparts, because of the stress of living in a world with discrimination9(Adam et al., 2015; Hostinar, McQuillan, Mirous, Grant, & Adam, 2014) and this biological dysregulation leads to subclinical disease, chronic physical illnesses, risky health behavior, negative emotional health and psychiatric disorders(Williams, Lawrence, Davis, & Vu, 2019). It is clear from the evidence that much more needs to be done in addressing race/ethnicity. Today, accountable health organizations have already identified that risk stratification together with social determinants of health is a way to divide patients into risk stratifications however if individuals are already prone to chronically elevated stress levels, or elevated systemic inflammatory markers just by the colour of their skin(Lucas et al., 2017; McEwen, 2012) and how they are treated by society, then it’s clear if bias affects how a minority health responds to stress and if there is greater trust towards interacting with those of similar ethnicity then healthcare can help model an intervention that addresses and mitigates societal institutional racism by hiring and engaging more minorities in clinical and leadership positions moreover an understanding of this knowledge can help leaders, clinicians, and health care planners to tailor health care needs to address the patient's physiological impact and also to help mitigate through the introduction of health policy and interventions of organizational strategy to remove institutional or structural racism within the workplace and the community.
Clinician and leadership representation
Efforts to eliminate disparities should begin with diversity in leadership and clinicians. Evidence supports better outcomes when a patient’s provider is also an underrepresented minority (Hughes, Varma, Pettigrew, & Albert, 2017)moreover providers from Black, Indigenous and People of Colour communities are more likely to serve in rural, underserved neighbourhoods and treat poor payor mix patients(Marrast, Zallman, Woolhandler, Bor, & McCormick, 2014) Except for the chief diversity position representing 77% Black, Indigenous and People of Colour (Goode & Landefeld, 2018), executive leadership representation in every C-suite position has either decreased or remained flat since 2013. In 2015 AHA Institute for Diversity and Health Equity's latest benchmark study showed that minorities represent only 11% of executive leadership positions. This number is slightly higher for Board Members and mid-level managers.
The future
Racial health disparities disrespect the United States promise of equal opportunity for all and have numerous costs to our society. People are calling for greater diversity in the Police however, racial disparities are so deeply ingrained within our society and addressing Police is only one aspect. The reality is we need greater diversity in all areas of society. The World Health Organization state health “The enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being without distinction of race, religion, political belief, economic or social condition.” (Ghebreyesus, 2017)Today we see a racial distinction that we must work harder to mitigate. The solution is no different than every other area that is struggling to attain equality; it begins by creating diversity. In healthcare, it starts with greater diversity in leadership (decision making), education (health knowledge) clinician (health delivery), community leaders (health advocacy); it is this collaboration that will help change what we have seen and continue to see amongst our community.
A tectonic shift is occurring with the public protests and a sense of the urgency appears to be occurring. Today in response to the protests many organizations are realizing that a change must occur. It’s unfortunate that the desire to change has taken so long. These organizations are communicating with their staff, admitting to lack of diversity, hearing personal stories from employees and starting the conversation of how race and racism exists within all strands of society. Specifically, in healthcare and how to improve the care, everyone’s knowledge and people’s attitude towards race and diversity. These conversations are the first step towards a solution and the next step is the most important to create change by doing something tangible and transformational by hiring minorities into key positions. This strategy is the biggest and most important step to changing the complexion within healthcare.
Adam, E. K., Heissel, J. A., Zeiders, K. H., Richeson, J. A., Ross, E. C., Ehrlich, K. B., . . . Malanchuk, O. (2015). Developmental histories of perceived racial discrimination and diurnal cortisol profiles in adulthood: A 20-year prospective study. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 62, 279-291.
Allen, E. M., Call, K. T., Beebe, T. J., McAlpine, D. D., & Johnson, P. J. (2017). Barriers to care and healthcare utilization among the publicly insured. Medical care, 55(3), 207.
Alsan, M., Garrick, O., & Graziani, G. (2019). Does diversity matter for health? Experimental evidence from Oakland. American Economic Review, 109(12), 4071-4111.
Ferdinand, K. C., Yadav, K., Nasser, S. A., Clayton‐Jeter, H. D., Lewin, J., Cryer, D. R., & Senatore, F. F. (2017). Disparities in hypertension and cardiovascular disease in blacks: the critical role of medication adherence. The Journal of Clinical Hypertension, 19(10), 1015-1024.
Ghebreyesus, T. A. (2017). Health is a fundamental human right. World Health Organization, Dec, 10.
Goode, C. A., & Landefeld, T. (2018). The Lack of Diversity in Healthcare. Journal of Best Practices in Health Professions Diversity, 11(2), 73-95.
Henning-Smith, C., Hernandez, A. M., Ramirez, M., Hardeman, R., & Kozhimannil, K. (2019). Dying too soon: County-level disparities in premature death by rurality, race, and ethnicity. Paper presented at the 2019 Annual Research Meeting.
Hostetter, M., & Klein, S. (2018). In focus: Reducing racial disparities in health care by confronting racism. Commonwealth Fund, September, 27, 121-127.
Hostinar, C. E., McQuillan, M. T., Mirous, H. J., Grant, K. E., & Adam, E. K. (2014). Cortisol responses to a group public speaking task for adolescents: variations by age, gender, and race. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 50, 155-166.
Howard, J. T. (2020). US Black–White Mortality Disparities: Still Unequal, Still Unjust. In: American Public Health Association.
Hughes, T. B., Varma, V. R., Pettigrew, C., & Albert, M. S. (2017). African Americans and clinical research: evidence concerning barriers and facilitators to participation and recruitment recommendations. The Gerontologist, 57(2), 348-358.
Ibarra, M., Montoya, X., Romero, C., & Gonzalez, G. (2018). Discrimination in the Health Care Setting Among Latinx in California.
Khullar, D. (2018). Even as the U.S. grows more diverse, the medical profession is slow to follow. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/even-as-the-us-grows-more-diverse-the-medical-profession-is-slow-to-follow/2018/09/21/6e048d66-aba4-11e8-a8d7-0f63ab8b1370_story.html
Laurencin, C. T., & McClinton, A. (2020). The COVID-19 pandemic: a call to action to identify and address racial and ethnic disparities. Journal of racial and ethnic health disparities, 1-5.
LaVeist, T. A., Gaskin, D., & Richard, P. (2011). Estimating the economic burden of racial health inequalities in the United States. International Journal of Health Services, 41(2), 231-238.
Lucas, T., Wegner, R., Pierce, J., Lumley, M. A., Laurent, H. K., & Granger, D. A. (2017). Perceived discrimination, racial identity, and multisystem stress response to social evaluative threat among African American men and women. Psychosomatic medicine, 79(3), 293.
Marrast, L. M., Zallman, L., Woolhandler, S., Bor, D. H., & McCormick, D. (2014). Minority physicians’ role in the care of underserved patients: diversifying the physician workforce may be key in addressing health disparities. JAMA internal medicine, 174(2), 289-291.
McEwen, B. S. (2012). Brain on stress: how the social environment gets under the skin. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(Supplement 2), 17180-17185.
National Academies of Sciences, E., & Medicine. (2017). Communities in action: Pathways to health equity: National Academies Press.
Tempe, D. K., & Dhir, A. (2019). Ethnicity and Health Care. Journal of cardiothoracic and vascular anesthesia, 33(2), 394-395.
Williams, D. R., Lawrence, J. A., Davis, B. A., & Vu, C. (2019). Understanding how discrimination can affect health. Health Services Research, 54, 1374-1388.
Yearby, R. (2018). Racial disparities in health status and access to healthcare: the continuation of inequality in the United States due to structural racism. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 77(3-4), 1113-1152.